I wish I would have noticed your post when you first posted b/c I was also teaching nature of science at that time. I don't know if this will help you now, but here are some gestures that helped my fifth graders.
For the independent and control variables, we used our hand. We hold up our hand and for the four fingers we say "same, same, same, same" and then when we get to the thumb, we say "different."
So for your independent and control variables, you could use that same gesture but you might say "control, control, control, control" instead of "same." And when you get to the thumb, you can say "independent" instead of "different."