If you did a turkey, could you add feathers to it? Instead of a tally, their turkey gets a feather if they earn a point...your turkey gets a feather if you earn a point. I like the gobble, gobble for them to say if they get a point, and I'm trying to come up with something if you get a point. I may need the weekend to think on that one!
For the indian, you could have a pic of an indian and then a pic of a headdress because you're the chief. They can make a Tomahawk movement and say, "oh, oh, oooooh." In an indian chant sound, real quick. If you get a point, they can say, "Hail to the Chief!"
We are the Jackson Indians, so I have some fun games that have that theme like "Chiefs and Indians." We use multiplication flash cards and if they win the scoreboard, we play this game. Everyone gets to go outside and run. I have 3-5 students who are the chiefs. If they get tagged by a chief, they have to see the big chief (me), and answer a multiplication fact in order to go run around the indian village again.
I'll try to come up with something for the turkey and get back with you!
Hope this helps!
Staci